In short
- Personalised book vs football kit comes down to what happens after six months.
- A kit is worn constantly and then outgrown, usually within a season.
- Shirts also date when a sponsor changes or a named player leaves.
- A book with the child’s name does not change size or go out of date.
A replica shirt is the most popular football gift for a child and the one most likely to be duplicated or outgrown.
Make them the star of their club's storyA personalised, hand-drawn football book for more than 100 clubs. £24.95Find their clubHere is the honest comparison of a personalised book vs football kit.

Personalised book vs football kit: which gets used more?
The kit, easily, in the first few months. A child will wear a replica shirt to the park, to bed and to school on non-uniform day.
Nothing a book can do competes with that level of use.
So if the question is immediate enjoyment, the kit wins and it is not close.
Which one lasts longer?
The book, by a wide margin. A replica kit is sized, so it is outgrown, usually inside a year for a growing child.
Kits also date. Clubs release new designs regularly, sponsors change, and a shirt with a player’s name on the back is awkward the moment that player is sold.
A book with a child’s own name in it is not sized and does not have a sponsor.
Does the duplication problem matter?
Quite a lot in practice. The shirt is the first thing every relative thinks of, so with three or four people buying independently a child can end up with multiple identical shirts.
Nobody else can order the same personalised book, because it has one child’s name in it.
That is the practical difference rather than a sentimental one.
Personalised book vs football kit for a reluctant reader
Reading enjoyment is at a twenty-year low: the National Literacy Trust put it at 32.7% of 8 to 18 year olds in 2025.
A football book gets past that resistance because the subject already matters to the child.
Writing on children’s books finds children engage most with material in which they are personally invested.
What is the honest answer?
Buy the kit if nobody else is, and the child needs one. Buy the book if the kit is covered, or if you want the gift that is still in the house in three years.
We sell the books, so treat that as an interested view rather than a neutral one. The kit argument is real and worth stating plainly.
Can you do both?
The common arrangement is parents buying the kit, since it is partly a running cost, and grandparents or other relatives buying the keepsake.
That split avoids duplication and covers both the immediate and the lasting.
What personalisation involves
Our book design page shows how a book is put together, including the name, number and inside message.
Our illustrated football books cover clubs across every English league, our guide to books by age covers 5 to 12, and the wider football books range includes smaller clubs.



More than 100 clubs
Make them the star of their club's story
- Their name and shirt number on the cover
- Hair colour, skin tone and eye colour to match them
- Your own message printed inside
- Every page hand-drawn by a human artist, with no AI artwork
For ages 5 to 12. Made to order for your child.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which gets used more? The kit, by a long way, in the first months.
Which lasts longer? The book, because it is not sized and does not date.
Why does duplication matter? The shirt is what everybody buys, so children end up with several.
Can you buy both? Yes, and the usual split is parents on kit, relatives on keepsake.
Create their book